Hughes, Australian Prime Minister in the First World War and leader of the Federal United Australia Party (the famous “Billy Hughes”), immediately said that it would be “suicidal and a false and dangerous policy for Australia to regard Britain’s support as being less important than that of other great associated countries.” There was a keen controversy in Australia. I cabled from Washington to Mr. Attlee: “I hope there will be The Hinge of Fate

24

no pandering to this, while at the same time we do all in human power to come to their aid….” I weighed painfully in my mind the idea of making a broadcast direct to the Australian people. At the same time I fully accepted the responsibility which fell on me. “I hope you will endeavour to let all issues stand over until I return, so that I may face any opposition myself…. If the Malay peninsula has been starved for the sake of Libya and Russia, no one is more responsible than I, and I would do exactly the same again.

Should any questions be asked in Parliament I should be glad if it could be stated that I particularly desire to answer them myself on my return.”

I replied at once to Mr. Curtin on the military position: Prime Minister to Mr.

3 Jan. 42

Curtin

General Wavell’s command area is limited to the fighting zone where active operations are now proceeding. Henceforward it does not include Australia, New Zealand, and communications between the United States and Australia, or indeed any other ocean communications. This does not of course mean that these vital regions and communications are to be left without protection so far as our resources admit. In our view, the American Navy should assume the responsibility for the communications, including the islands right up to the Australian or New Zealand coast. This is what we are pressing for. Admiral King has only just been given full powers over the whole of the American Navy, and he has not yet accepted our views. Obviously, if I cannot persuade the Americans to take over, we shall have to fill the gap as best we can, but I still hope our views will be accepted, in which case of course any vessels we or you have in that area will come under United States direction while operating there. There never has been any intention to make the main Allied The Hinge of Fate

25

concentration in the newly defined Southwest Pacific theatre, and I do not know where you got this from….

Night and day I am labouring here to make the best arrangements possible in your interests and for your safety, having regard to the other theatres and the other dangers which have to be met from our limited resources. It is only a little while ago that you were most strongly urging the highest state of equipment for the Australian Army in the Middle East. The battle there is still not finished, though the prospects arc good. It would have been folly to spoil Auchinleck’s battle by diverting aircraft, tanks, etc., to the Malay peninsula at a time when there was no certainty that Japan would enter the war. The ease-up of the Caucasian danger through the Russian victories and the Auchinleck successes have made possible the considerable reinforcements, at the temporary expense of the Middle East, of which you have been advised, and which are also justified because Malaya has now become a war theatre….

Continuous interchanges took place between me and Mr.

Curtin.

Prime Minister of

11 Jan. 42

Australia to Prime

Minister

It is naturally disturbing to learn that the Japanese have been able to overrun so easily the whole of Malaya except Johore and that the Commander-in-Chief considers that certain risks have to be accepted even now in carrying on his plan for the defence of this limited area.

It is observed that the 8th Australian Division is to be given the task of fighting the decisive battle. The Government has no doubt that it will acquit itself in accordance with the highest traditions of the Australian Imperial Force. However, I urge on you that nothing be left undone to reinforce Malaya to the greatest degree possible in accordance with my earlier representations The Hinge of Fate

26

and your intentions. I am particularly concerned in regard to air strength, as a repetition of the Greece and Crete campaigns would evoke a violent public reaction, and such a happening should be placed outside the bounds of possibility.