Perkupp sent for me and told me that my position
would be that of one of the senior clerks. I was more than
overjoyed. Mr. Perkupp added, he would let me know to-morrow
what the salary would be. This means another day’s anxiety; I
don’t mind, for it is anxiety of the right sort. That
reminded me that I had forgotten to speak to Lupin about the letter
I received from Mr. Mutlar, senr. I broached the subject to
Lupin in the evening, having first consulted Carrie. Lupin
was riveted to the Financial News, as if he had been a born
capitalist, and I said: “Pardon me a moment, Lupin, how is it you
have not been to the Mutlars’ any day this week?”
Lupin answered: “I told you! I cannot stand old
Mutlar.”
I said: “Mr. Mutlar writes to me to say pretty plainly that he
cannot stand you!”
Lupin said: “Well, I like his cheek in writing to
you. I’ll find out if his father is still alive, and I
will write him a note complaining of his son, and
I’ll state pretty clearly that his son is a blithering idiot!”
I said: “Lupin, please moderate your expressions in the presence
of your mother.”
Lupin said: “I’m very sorry, but there is no other expression
one can apply to him. However, I’m determined not to enter
his place again.”
I said: “You know, Lupin, he has forbidden you the house.”
Lupin replied: “Well, we won’t split straws—it’s all the
same. Daisy is a trump, and will wait for me ten years, if
necessary.”
January 5.—I can scarcely write the news. Mr. Perkupp told
me my salary would be raised £100! I stood gaping for a
moment unable to realise it. I annually get £10 rise, and I
thought it might be £15 or even £20; but £100 surpasses all
belief. Carrie and I both rejoiced over our good
fortune. Lupin came home in the evening in the utmost good
spirits. I sent Sarah quietly round to the grocer’s for a
bottle of champagne, the same as we had before, “Jackson
Frères.” It was opened at supper, and I said to Lupin: “This
is to celebrate some good news I have received to-day.” Lupin
replied: “Hooray, Guv.! And I have some good news, also; a
double event, eh?” I said: “My boy, as a result of twenty-one
years’ industry and strict attention to the interests of my
superiors in office, I have been rewarded with promotion and a rise
in salary of £100.”
Lupin gave three cheers, and we rapped the table furiously,
which brought in Sarah to see what the matter was. Lupin
ordered us to “fill up” again, and addressing us upstanding, said:
“Having been in the firm of Job Cleanands, stock and share-brokers,
a few weeks, and not having paid particular attention to the
interests of my superiors in office, my Guv’nor, as a reward to me,
allotted me £5 worth of shares in a really good thing. The
result is, to-day I have made £200.” I said: “Lupin, you are
joking.” “No, Guv., it’s the good old truth; Job Cleanands
put me on to Chlorates.”
January 21.—I am very much concerned at Lupin having started a
pony-trap. I said: “Lupin, are you justified in this
outrageous extravagance?” Lupin replied: “Well, one must get
to the City somehow. I’ve only hired it, and can give it up
any time I like.” I repeated my question: “Are you justified
in this extravagance?” He replied: “Look here, Guv., excuse
me saying so, but you’re a bit out of date. It does not pay
nowadays, fiddling about over small things. I don’t mean
anything personal, Guv’nor. My boss says if I take his tip,
and stick to big things, I can make big money!” I said I
thought the very idea of speculation most horrifying. Lupin
said “It is not speculation, it’s a dead cert.” I advised
him, at all events, not to continue the pony and cart; but he
replied: “I made £200 in one day; now suppose I only make £200 in a
month, or put it at £100 a month, which is ridiculously low—why,
that is £1,250 a year. What’s a few pounds a week for a
trap?”
I did not pursue the subject further, beyond saying that I
should feel glad when the autumn came, and Lupin would be of age
and responsible for his own debts. He answered: “My dear
Guv., I promise you faithfully that I will never speculate with
what I have not got. I shall only go on Job Cleanands’ tips,
and as he is in the ‘know’ it is pretty safe sailing.” I felt
somewhat relieved. Gowing called in the evening and, to my
surprise, informed me that, as he had made £10 by one of Lupin’s
tips, he intended asking us and the Cummings round next
Saturday. Carrie and I said we should be delighted.
January 22.—I don’t generally lose my temper with servants; but
I had to speak to Sarah rather sharply about a careless habit she
has recently contracted of shaking the table-cloth, after removing
the breakfast things, in a manner which causes all the crumbs to
fall on the carpet, eventually to be trodden in. Sarah
answered very rudely: “Oh, you are always complaining.” I
replied: “Indeed, I am not. I spoke to you last week about
walking all over the drawing-room carpet with a piece of yellow
soap on the heel of your boot.” She said: “And you’re always
grumbling about your breakfast.” I said: “No, I am not; but I
feel perfectly justified in complaining that I never can get a
hard-boiled egg. The moment I crack the shell it spurts all
over the plate, and I have spoken to you at least fifty times about
it.” She began to cry and make a scene; but fortunately my
’bus came by, so I had a good excuse for leaving her. Gowing
left a message in the evening, that we were not to forget next
Saturday. Carrie amusingly said: As he has never asked any
friends before, we are not likely to forget it.
January 23.—I asked Lupin to try and change the hard brushes, he
recently made me a present of, for some softer ones, as my
hair-dresser tells me I ought not to brush my hair too much just
now.
January 24.—The new chimney-glass came home for the back
drawing-room. Carrie arranged some fans very prettily on the
top and on each side. It is an immense improvement to the
room.
January 25.—We had just finished our tea, when who should come
in but Cummings, who has not been here for over three weeks.
I noticed that he looked anything but well, so I said: “Well,
Cummings, how are you? You look a little blue.” He
replied: “Yes! and I feel blue too.” I said: “Why, what’s the
matter?” He said: “Oh, nothing, except that I have been on my
back for a couple of weeks, that’s all. At one time my doctor
nearly gave me up, yet not a soul has come near me. No one
has even taken the trouble to inquire whether I was alive or
dead.”
I said: “This is the first I have heard of it. I have
passed your house several nights, and presumed you had company, as
the rooms were so brilliantly lighted.”
Cummings replied: “No! The only company I have had was my
wife, the doctor, and the landlady—the last-named having turned out
a perfect trump. I wonder you did not see it in the
paper. I know it was mentioned in the Bicycle
News.”
I thought to cheer him up, and said: “Well, you are all right
now?”
He replied: “That’s not the question. The question is
whether an illness does not enable you to discover who are your
true friends.”
I said such an observation was unworthy of him. To make
matters worse, in came Gowing, who gave Cummings a violent slap on
the back, and said: “Hulloh! Have you seen a ghost? You
look scared to death, like Irving in Macbeth.” I said:
“Gently, Gowing, the poor fellow has been very ill.” Gowing
roared with laughter and said: “Yes, and you look it, too.”
Cummings quietly said: “Yes, and I feel it too—not that I suppose
you care.”
An awkward silence followed. Gowing said: “Never mind,
Cummings, you and the missis come round to my place to-morrow, and
it will cheer you up a bit; for we’ll open a bottle of wine.”
January 26.—An extraordinary thing happened. Carrie and I
went round to Gowing’s, as arranged, at half-past seven. We
knocked and rang several times without getting an answer. At
last the latch was drawn and the door opened a little way, the
chain still being up. A man in shirt-sleeves put his head
through and said: “Who is it? What do you want?” I said: “Mr.
Gowing, he is expecting us.” The man said (as well as I could
hear, owing to the yapping of a little dog): “I don’t think he
is. Mr. Gowing is not at home.” I said: “He will be in
directly.”
With that observation he slammed the door, leaving Carrie and me
standing on the steps with a cutting wind blowing round the
corner.
Carrie advised me to knock again. I did so, and then
discovered for the first time that the knocker had been newly
painted, and the paint had come off on my gloves—which were, in
consequence, completely spoiled.
I knocked at the door with my stick two or three times.
The man opened the door, taking the chain off this time, and
began abusing me. He said: “What do you mean by scratching
the paint with your stick like that, spoiling the varnish?
You ought to be ashamed of yourself.”
I said: “Pardon me, Mr. Gowing invited—”
He interrupted and said: “I don’t care for Mr. Gowing, or any of
his friends. This is my door, not Mr. Gowing’s.
There are people here besides Mr. Gowing.”
The impertinence of this man was nothing. I scarcely
noticed it, it was so trivial in comparison with the scandalous
conduct of Gowing.
At this moment Cummings and his wife arrived. Cummings was
very lame and leaning on a stick; but got up the steps and asked
what the matter was.
The man said: “Mr. Gowing said nothing about expecting
anyone. All he said was he had just received an invitation to
Croydon, and he should not be back till Monday evening. He
took his bag with him.”
With that he slammed the door again. I was too indignant
with Gowing’s conduct to say anything. Cummings looked white
with rage, and as he descended the steps struck his stick violently
on the ground and said: “Scoundrel!”
CHAPTER XV
Gowing explains his conduct. Lupin takes us for a drive,
which we don’t enjoy. Lupin introduces us to Mr. Murray
Posh.
February 8.—It does seem hard I cannot get good sausages for
breakfast. They are either full of bread or spice, or are as
red as beef. Still anxious about the £20 I invested last week
by Lupin’s advice. However, Cummings has done the same.
February 9.—Exactly a fortnight has passed, and I have neither
seen nor heard from Gowing respecting his extraordinary conduct in
asking us round to his house, and then being out. In the
evening Carrie was engaged marking a half-dozen new collars I had
purchased. I’ll back Carrie’s marking against
anybody’s. While I was drying them at the fire, and Carrie
was rebuking me for scorching them, Cummings came in.
He seemed quite well again, and chaffed us about marking the
collars. I asked him if he had heard from Gowing, and he
replied that he had not. I said I should not have believed
that Gowing could have acted in such an ungentlemanly manner.
Cummings said: “You are mild in your description of him; I think he
has acted like a cad.”
The words were scarcely out of his mouth when the door opened,
and Gowing, putting in his head, said: “May I come in?” I
said: “Certainly.” Carrie said very pointedly: “Well, you
are a stranger.” Gowing said: “Yes, I’ve been on and
off to Croydon during the last fortnight.” I could see
Cummings was boiling over, and eventually he tackled Gowing very
strongly respecting his conduct last Saturday week. Gowing
appeared surprised, and said: “Why, I posted a letter to you in the
morning announcing that the party was ‘off, very much off.’”
I said: “I never got it.” Gowing, turning to Carrie, said: “I
suppose letters sometimes miscarry, don’t they, Mrs.
Carrie?” Cummings sharply said: “This is not a time for
joking. I had no notice of the party being put off.”
Gowing replied: “I told Pooter in my note to tell you, as I was in
a hurry. However, I’ll inquire at the post-office, and we
must meet again at my place.” I added that I hoped he would
be present at the next meeting. Carrie roared at this, and
even Cummings could not help laughing.
February 10, Sunday.—Contrary to my wishes, Carrie allowed Lupin
to persuade her to take her for a drive in the afternoon in his
trap. I quite disapprove of driving on a Sunday, but I did
not like to trust Carrie alone with Lupin, so I offered to go
too. Lupin said: “Now, that is nice of you, Guv., but you
won’t mind sitting on the back-seat of the cart?”
Lupin proceeded to put on a bright-blue coat that seemed miles
too large for him. Carrie said it wanted taking in
considerably at the back. Lupin said: “Haven’t you seen a
box-coat before? You can’t drive in anything else.”
He may wear what he likes in the future, for I shall never drive
with him again. His conduct was shocking. When we
passed Highgate Archway, he tried to pass everything and
everybody. He shouted to respectable people who were walking
quietly in the road to get out of the way; he flicked at the horse
of an old man who was riding, causing it to rear; and, as I had to
ride backwards, I was compelled to face a gang of roughs in a
donkey-cart, whom Lupin had chaffed, and who turned and followed us
for nearly a mile, bellowing, indulging in coarse jokes and
laughter, to say nothing of occasionally pelting us with
orange-peel.
Lupin’s excuse—that the Prince of Wales would have to put up
with the same sort of thing if he drove to the Derby—was of little
consolation to either Carrie or myself. Frank Mutlar called
in the evening, and Lupin went out with him.
February 11.—Feeling a little concerned about Lupin, I mustered
up courage to speak to Mr. Perkupp about him. Mr. Perkupp has
always been most kind to me, so I told him everything, including
yesterday’s adventure. Mr. Perkupp kindly replied: “There is
no necessity for you to be anxious, Mr. Pooter. It would be
impossible for a son of such good parents to turn out
erroneously. Remember he is young, and will soon get
older. I wish we could find room for him in this firm.”
The advice of this good man takes loads off my mind. In the
evening Lupin came in.
After our little supper, he said: “My dear parents, I have some
news, which I fear will affect you considerably.” I felt a
qualm come over me, and said nothing. Lupin then said: “It
may distress you—in fact, I’m sure it will—but this afternoon I
have given up my pony and trap for ever.” It may seem absurd,
but I was so pleased, I immediately opened a bottle of port.
Gowing dropped in just in time, bringing with him a large sheet,
with a print of a tailless donkey, which he fastened against the
wall. He then produced several separate tails, and we spent
the remainder of the evening trying blindfolded to pin a tail on in
the proper place. My sides positively ached with laughter
when I went to bed.
February 12.—In the evening I spoke to Lupin about his
engagement with Daisy Mutlar. I asked if he had heard from
her. He replied: “No; she promised that old windbag of a
father of hers that she would not communicate with me. I see
Frank Mutlar, of course; in fact, he said he might call again this
evening.” Frank called, but said he could not stop, as he had
a friend waiting outside for him, named Murray Posh, adding he was
quite a swell. Carrie asked Frank to bring him in.
He was brought in, Gowing entering at the same time. Mr.
Murray Posh was a tall, fat young man, and was evidently of a very
nervous disposition, as he subsequently confessed he would never go
in a hansom cab, nor would he enter a four-wheeler until the driver
had first got on the box with his reins in his hands.
On being introduced, Gowing, with his usual want of tact, said:
“Any relation to ‘Posh’s three-shilling hats’?” Mr. Posh
replied: “Yes; but please understand I don’t try on hats
myself. I take no active part in the business.”
I replied: “I wish I had a business like it.” Mr. Posh seemed
pleased, and gave a long but most interesting history of the
extraordinary difficulties in the manufacture of cheap hats.
Murray Posh evidently knew Daisy Mutlar very intimately from the
way he was talking of her; and Frank said to Lupin once,
laughingly: “If you don’t look out, Posh will cut you out!”
When they had all gone, I referred to this flippant conversation;
and Lupin said, sarcastically: “A man who is jealous has no respect
for himself. A man who would be jealous of an elephant like
Murray Posh could only have a contempt for himself. I know
Daisy. She would wait ten years for me, as I said
before; in fact, if necessary, she would wait twenty years for
me.”
CHAPTER XVI
We lose money over Lupin’s advice as to investment, so does
Cummings. Murray Posh engaged to Daisy Mutlar.
February 18.—Carrie has several times recently called attention
to the thinness of my hair at the top of my head, and recommended
me to get it seen to. I was this morning trying to look at it
by the aid of a small hand-glass, when somehow my elbow caught
against the edge of the chest of drawers and knocked the glass out
of my hand and smashed it. Carrie was in an awful way about
it, as she is rather absurdly superstitious. To make matters
worse, my large photograph in the drawing-room fell during the
night, and the glass cracked.
Carrie said: “Mark my words, Charles, some misfortune is about
to happen.”
I said: “Nonsense, dear.”
In the evening Lupin arrived home early, and seemed a little
agitated. I said: “What’s up, my boy?” He hesitated a
good deal, and then said: “You know those Parachikka Chlorates I
advised you to invest £20 in? I replied: “Yes, they are all
right, I trust?” He replied: “Well, no! To the surprise
of everybody, they have utterly collapsed.”
My breath was so completely taken away, I could say
nothing. Carrie looked at me, and said: “What did I tell
you?” Lupin, after a while, said: “However, you are specially
fortunate. I received an early tip, and sold out yours
immediately, and was fortunate to get £2 for them. So you get
something after all.”
I gave a sigh of relief. I said: “I was not so sanguine as
to suppose, as you predicted, that I should get six or eight times
the amount of my investment; still a profit of £2 is a good
percentage for such a short time.” Lupin said, quite
irritably: “You don’t understand. I sold your £20 shares for
£2; you therefore lose £18 on the transaction, whereby Cummings and
Gowing will lose the whole of theirs.”
February 19.—Lupin, before going to town, said: “I am very sorry
about those Parachikka Chlorates; it would not have happened if the
boss, Job Cleanands, had been in town. Between ourselves, you
must not be surprised if something goes wrong at our office.
Job Cleanands has not been seen the last few days, and it strikes
me several people do want to see him very particularly.”
In the evening Lupin was just on the point of going out to avoid
a collision with Gowing and Cummings, when the former entered the
room, without knocking, but with his usual trick of saying, “May I
come in?”
He entered, and to the surprise of Lupin and myself, seemed to
be in the very best of spirits. Neither Lupin nor I broached
the subject to him, but he did so of his own accord. He said:
“I say, those Parachikka Chlorates have gone an awful smash!
You’re a nice one, Master Lupin. How much do you lose?”
Lupin, to my utter astonishment, said: “Oh! I had nothing in
them. There was some informality in my application—I forgot
to enclose the cheque or something, and I didn’t get any. The
Guv. loses £18.” I said: “I quite understood you were in it,
or nothing would have induced me to speculate.” Lupin
replied: “Well, it can’t be helped; you must go double on the next
tip.” Before I could reply, Gowing said: “Well, I lose
nothing, fortunately. From what I heard, I did not quite
believe in them, so I persuaded Cummings to take my £15 worth, as
he had more faith in them than I had.”
Lupin burst out laughing, and, in the most unseemly manner,
said: “Alas, poor Cummings. He’ll lose £35.” At that
moment there was a ring at the bell. Lupin said: “I don’t
want to meet Cummings.” If he had gone out of the door he
would have met him in the passage, so as quickly as possible Lupin
opened the parlour window and got out. Gowing jumped up
suddenly, exclaiming: “I don’t want to see him either!” and, before
I could say a word, he followed Lupin out of the window.
For my own part, I was horrified to think my own son and one of
my most intimate friends should depart from the house like a couple
of interrupted burglars. Poor Cummings was very upset, and of
course was naturally very angry both with Lupin and Gowing. I
pressed him to have a little whisky, and he replied that he had
given up whisky; but would like a little “Unsweetened,” as he was
advised it was the most healthy spirit. I had none in the
house, but sent Sarah round to Lockwood’s for some.
February 20.—The first thing that caught my eye on opening the
Standard was—“Great Failure of Stock and Share
Dealers! Mr. Job Cleanands absconded!” I handed it to
Carrie, and she replied: “Oh! perhaps it’s for Lupin’s good.
I never did think it a suitable situation for him.” I thought
the whole affair very shocking.
Lupin came down to breakfast, and seeing he looked painfully
distressed, I said: “We know the news, my dear boy, and feel very
sorry for you.” Lupin said: “How did you know? who told
you?” I handed him the Standard. He threw the
paper down, and said: “Oh I don’t care a button for that! I
expected that, but I did not expect this.” He then read a
letter from Frank Mutlar, announcing, in a cool manner, that Daisy
Mutlar is to be married next month to Murray Posh. I
exclaimed, “Murray Posh! Is not that the very man Frank had
the impudence to bring here last Tuesday week?” Lupin said:
“Yes; the ‘Posh’s-three-shilling-hats’ chap.”
We all then ate our breakfast in dead silence.
In fact, I could eat nothing. I was not only too worried,
but I cannot and will not eat cushion of bacon. If I cannot
get streaky bacon, I will do without anything.
When Lupin rose to go I noticed a malicious smile creep over his
face. I asked him what it meant. He replied: “Oh! only
a little consolation—still it is a consolation. I have just
remembered that, by my advice, Mr. Murray Posh has invested
£600 in Parachikka Chlorates!”
CHAPTER XVII
Marriage of Daisy Mutlar and Murray Posh. The dream of my
life realised. Mr. Perkupp takes Lupin into the office.
March 20.—To-day being the day on which Daisy Mutlar and Mr.
Murray Posh are to be married, Lupin has gone with a friend to
spend the day at Gravesend. Lupin has been much cut-up over
the affair, although he declares that he is glad it is off. I
wish he would not go to so many music-halls, but one dare not say
anything to him about it. At the present moment he irritates
me by singing all over the house some nonsense about “What’s the
matter with Gladstone? He’s all right! What’s the
matter with Lupin? He’s all right!” I don’t
think either of them is. In the evening Gowing called, and
the chief topic of conversation was Daisy’s marriage to Murray
Posh. I said: “I was glad the matter was at an end, as Daisy
would only have made a fool of Lupin.” Gowing, with his usual
good taste, said: “Oh, Master Lupin can make a fool of himself
without any assistance.” Carrie very properly resented this,
and Gowing had sufficient sense to say he was sorry.
March 21.—To-day I shall conclude my diary, for it is one of the
happiest days of my life. My great dream of the last few
weeks—in fact, of many years—has been realised. This morning
came a letter from Mr. Perkupp, asking me to take Lupin down to the
office with me. I went to Lupin’s room; poor fellow, he
seemed very pale, and said he had a bad headache. He had come
back yesterday from Gravesend, where he spent part of the day in a
small boat on the water, having been mad enough to neglect to take
his overcoat with him. I showed him Mr. Perkupp’s letter, and
he got up as quickly as possible. I begged of him not to put
on his fast-coloured clothes and ties, but to dress in something
black or quiet-looking.
Carrie was all of a tremble when she read the letter, and all
she could keep on saying was: “Oh, I do hope it will be all
right.” For myself, I could scarcely eat any breakfast.
Lupin came down dressed quietly, and looking a perfect gentleman,
except that his face was rather yellow. Carrie, by way of
encouragement said: “You do look nice, Lupin.” Lupin replied:
“Yes, it’s a good make-up, isn’t it? A
regular-downright-respectable-funereal-first-class-City-firm-junior-clerk.”
He laughed rather ironically.
In the hall I heard a great noise, and also Lupin shouting to
Sarah to fetch down his old hat. I went into the passage, and
found Lupin in a fury, kicking and smashing a new tall hat. I
said: “Lupin, my boy, what are you doing? How wicked of
you! Some poor fellow would be glad to have it.” Lupin
replied: “I would not insult any poor fellow by giving it to
him.”
When he had gone outside, I picked up the battered hat, and saw
inside “Posh’s Patent.” Poor Lupin! I can forgive
him. It seemed hours before we reached the office. Mr.
Perkupp sent for Lupin, who was with him nearly an hour. He
returned, as I thought, crestfallen in appearance. I said:
“Well, Lupin, how about Mr. Perkupp?” Lupin commenced his
song: “What’s the matter with Perkupp? He’s all right!”
I felt instinctively my boy was engaged. I went to Mr.
Perkupp, but I could not speak. He said: “Well, Mr. Pooter,
what is it?” I must have looked a fool, for all I could say
was: “Mr. Perkupp, you are a good man.” He looked at me for a
moment, and said: “No, Mr. Pooter, you are the good man; and
we’ll see if we cannot get your son to follow such an excellent
example.” I said: “Mr. Perkupp, may I go home? I cannot
work any more to-day.”
My good master shook my hand warmly as he nodded his head.
It was as much as I could do to prevent myself from crying in the
’bus; in fact, I should have done so, had my thoughts not been
interrupted by Lupin, who was having a quarrel with a fat man in
the ’bus, whom he accused of taking up too much room.
In the evening Carrie sent round for dear old friend Cummings
and his wife, and also to Gowing. We all sat round the fire,
and in a bottle of “Jackson Frères,” which Sarah fetched from the
grocer’s, drank Lupin’s health. I lay awake for hours,
thinking of the future. My boy in the same office as
myself—we can go down together by the ’bus, come home together, and
who knows but in the course of time he may take great interest in
our little home. That he may help me to put a nail in here or
a nail in there, or help his dear mother to hang a picture.
In the summer he may help us in our little garden with the flowers,
and assist us to paint the stands and pots. (By-the-by, I
must get in some more enamel paint.) All this I thought over
and over again, and a thousand happy thoughts beside. I heard
the clock strike four, and soon after fell asleep, only to dream of
three happy people—Lupin, dear Carrie, and myself.
CHAPTER XVIII
Trouble with a stylographic pen. We go to a Volunteer
Ball, where I am let in for an expensive supper. Grossly
insulted by a cabman. An odd invitation to Southend.
April 8.—No events of any importance, except that Gowing
strongly recommended a new patent stylographic pen, which cost me
nine-and-sixpence, and which was simply nine-and-sixpence thrown in
the mud. It has caused me constant annoyance and irritability
of temper. The ink oozes out of the top, making a mess on my
hands, and once at the office when I was knocking the palm of my
hand on the desk to jerk the ink down, Mr. Perkupp, who had just
entered, called out: “Stop that knocking! I suppose that is
you, Mr.
1 comment