I look back on

Times when we never heard of love.

His mother would have sent me packing

(God rest her soul in heaven above).”

“But how did you get married, Nanny?”

“It must have been God’s will. My Vanya

Was not as old as me, my dear,

And I was in my fourteenth year.

A matchmaker came over, plying

My kinsfolk for a week or two,

The father gave the blessing due,

Which left me bitter, scared and crying.

They cried too, shaking out my hair

For church, and then they sang me there.

19

So I was sent to a new family…

…But you’ve not heard a word I’ve said…”

“I’m feeling awful, dearest Nanny,

I have a kind of sickly dread.

I could start crying, sobbing.” “Surely,

My little one, you must be poorly.

God save you in his mercy, dear.

What do you want? Ask, I am here.

I’ll sprinkle you with holy water.

You’re burning hot…” “I’m not ill, though,

Nanny… I’m… I’m in love.” “Oh, no,

The Lord be with you!” Nanny caught her,

Prayed softly for Tatyana, and

Crossed the maid with her small, frail hand.

20

“Yes, I’m in love,” again she whispered,

Lamenting in a doleful tone.

“You’re feeling poorly, sweetheart. Listen…”

“No, I’m in love. Leave me alone.”

And all the time the moon was glowing

With a subdued light, clearly showing

The maiden’s pale charms, and her hair

Undone and scattered everywhere,

Her tears, and near the young Tatyana

Her nanny on the wooden seat,

A scarf on her grey head, complete

With her long-hanging body-warmer.

Silence and dreams. The moon on high

An inspiration in the sky.

21

Tatyana’s heart was feeling freer

As she gazed at the moon, and lo!

She had an interesting idea.

“I want to be alone. Please go,

Nanny, but give me pen and paper.

Bring me that table. I’ll sleep later.

I’m sorry.” And when she has gone

Stillness descends… The moon shines on…

Head propped on elbow, Tanya forges

Ahead with writing (him in mind)

A hasty missive to be signed

By an ingénue lovelorn and gorgeous…

The letter’s done, folded in two.

But, Tanya—who is it going to?

22

I’ve known intractable young beauties

As cool and pure as driven snow,

Implacable, non-venal cuties,

Not for the minds of men—oh, no!

They faze me, modish and high-minded;

Their virtue has good blood behind it.

Yes, I admit to having fled,

Methinks with horror, once I read

Upon their brows that phrase from Hades:

Abandon hope now for all time.

To rouse love is, for them, a crime;

Deterrence gratifies these ladies,

And maybe by the Neva, you

Have come across such persons too.

23

With worshippers no less subservient

Other strange females I have seen

Who were self-centred and impervious

To sighs of love and flattery.

What did I find? I was astonished:

Those austere girls who had admonished,

And turned down shy love, did not lack

The clever skills to win it back,

At least by showing some compassion.

At least in the odd spoken word

A touch of tenderness was heard,

And in his unperceiving fashion

A blind and gullible young swain

Would strive for his sweet dreams again.

24

What is Tatyana’s worst transgression?

That in her sweet way she has been

Free from deceit? Her one obsession

Has been to trust her chosen dream?

Or that she loves without art, yielding

To the seductive call of feeling?

That she is trustingly naive?

That heaven chose her to receive

Imagination of wild splendour,

A will so sharp, a mind so shrewd,

A head so full of attitude,

A heart so passionate and tender?

Forgive! She’s only guilty of

Scatterbrain tendencies in love.

25

Whereas a flirt will judge things coldly,

Tatyana loves with true intent.

She dedicates her spirit wholly

To love, with childlike innocence.

She doesn’t say, “No need to hurry,

Love’s price will rise, we need not worry,

Delay will lure things to our nets.

Let’s puncture vanity, and let’s

Use hope and bafflement together

To overwhelm a heart, and then

Bring it to jealous fire again.

For otherwise, sated with pleasure,

Our wily captive will respond

With a strong urge to burst his bonds.”

26

One further problem: I had better

Protect the honour of my land

By giving you Tatyana’s letter

Translated. You must understand:

Her grasp of Russian was defective,

Our Russian journals she neglected,

And found it hard to get along

With speakers of her mother tongue.

Her letter, then, was in French phrases.

What can we do about this—what?

Again I say: Russian was not

A medium fit for love and ladies.

Our worthy language, I suppose,

Has not grown into postal prose.

27

I know some people want to make them

Read Russian. Horrible indeed!

Is this how I should recreate them:

Clutching The Well-Wisher? Agreed!

Poets! I need to know for certain:

Is it not true that these sweet persons,

To whom you sinners have conveyed

In verse a secret serenade,

To whom you gave your hearts of marble—

How little Russian did they know!

But did they not strain at it so

That, in the end, however garbled,

The foreign language that was wrung

From them became their mother tongue?

28

I pray that at a ball I wouldn’t

Meet there, or on the porch mayhap,

A yellow-shawled religious student

Or academic in his cap.

Red lips are nothing when unsmiling,

And Russian speech is unbeguiling

Without grammatical mistakes.

Perhaps—ah, me! For Heaven’s sake—

Sweet girls in a new generation,

Hearing the journals’ siren voice,

Will teach us grammar as by choice,

And verse will add to the occasion.

But what has this to do with me?

I shall keep faith with history.

29

All incorrect and mindless chatter

And speech that is not of the best

Will always set my heart aflutter,

As long ago, within my breast.

I have no strength now for repentance,

I’ll take French words in any sentence,

And tolerate old sins and worse

With Bogdanóvich and his verse.

But that will do. I must get busy.

Tatyana’s letter is at stake.

I promised… But, for Heaven’s sake,

I could back out… I’m in a tizzy.

I know that Parny’s tender brogue

Has gone, and is no more in vogue.

30

Bard of The Feasts and aching sadness,

If only you were with me here.

I would approach with brazen gladness,

Old friend of mine, and bend your ear:

“Bring melody with magic laden

To this inflamed, impassioned maiden

And the French phrases she recites.

Where are you? Come to me! My rights

I yield to you. Your line is my line.”

But under the sad, beetling crags,

All praise gone by, his way he drags,

Alone beneath the Finnish skyline.

He wanders, knowing no relief,

And cannot hear me in my grief.

31

Tatyana’s letter lies before me.

I hold it like a holy thing.

I read it through in secret torment

With a delight unwavering.

Who taught her all these tender phrases,

The easy kindness that amazes?

Who taught her this warm gibberish,

This heartfelt talk so feverish,

So fascinating yet so tainting?

I cannot tell. This version here

Is poor and incomplete, I fear,

A thin take of a vibrant painting.

It’s like Der Freischütz tightly squeezed

From girl beginners at the keys.

TATYANA’S LETTER TO ONEGIN

    What can I do but write this letter

To you? Can I say something more?

I know that now you have the better

Of me, to punish me with scorn.

But if you, with my sad fate settled,

Retain one drop of sympathy,

You will not now abandon me.

At first I wanted to keep quiet.

Believe me, you would not have known

About the shame that I have shown,

If only I could have got by it

By simply hoping we might meet

Once weekly in the village street,

Or I might listen to you speaking,

And say a word to you, and then

Withdraw to think and think again,

Around the clock, of our next meeting.

But you’re unsociable, they say;

The country’s not exciting, is it?

And we… don’t shine in any way.

We’re plain, though welcoming your visit.

    Why did you come here? What to do?

In our remote, forgotten village

I would have known nothing of you,

Nor this raw suffering. God willing—

Who knows?—at long last, after stilling

The turmoil of a maiden soul,

I might have found a friend, a heartener,

I might have been his faithful partner,

And played a virtuous mother’s role.

    Another man? My heart will answer:

It cannot go to others, no.

This comes forth from the highest council:

By Heaven’s will I’m yours alone.

My life has long been dedicated

To meeting you, the person whom

I see as sent by God, and fated

To be my guardian to the tomb.

     In dreams I have divined your presence,

Dear to my heart, though still unseen,

Your dear glance pierced me with its gleam,

Your voice has stirred my soul with resonance

For some time now. No dream was this.

I knew you even as you entered;

I felt all faint, ablaze, tormented,

Telling myself: yes, here he is!

Did I not hear your voice engaging

With me whenever silence reigned,

When I was with the poor, or phrasing

A prayer to heaven, and assuaging

The anguish of a soul in pain?

    Here is a sudden apparition;

Is it not you, my dearest vision?

Through the bright dusk did you not slope,

Softly above my pillow bending,

Bringing delight and love while sending

To me the whispered words of hope?

What can you be—my guardian angel,

Or someone luring me into danger?

Scatter my doubts. I must be told.

Is this an empty dream created

By one who cheats a simple soul

While something different is fated?

    So be it. My destiny

Is in your hands, and I surrender.

I shed my tears for you to see,

And pray you will be my defender.

Picture me: I am all alone,

And no one knows me, nothing alters.

My senses reel, my reason falters,

I cannot speak, my life is gone.

I wait. Your glance has the potential

To raise new hope and hearten me

Or wreck my hard dream, giving me

What I deserve, alas!—your censure.

    I close, and dread to read this through.

I feel embarrassed, I feel frightened,

But honour is a pledge from you;

To this my trust is boldly plighted…

32

Now only sighs and moans escape her.

The letter trembles in her hand.

She licks at the pink-coloured wafer,

Dry on her fevered tongue-tip, and

Her darling head slumps at an angle,

Her light slip slides down in a tangle,

Laying a lovely shoulder bare,

And now the moonlight everywhere

Fades in its radiance. Mist comes creeping

Along the vale, the stream reborn

In silver light. The herdsman’s horn

Rouses the village from its sleeping.

Morning… Folk are long out of bed.

My Tanya isn’t interested.

33

She has not noticed the dawn breaking.

She sits, head bowed, in dishabille,

Viewing the letter without making

An imprint with her graven seal.

Then the door opens, slow and quiet;

Grey-haired Filípyevna stands by it,

Bearing a tray, tea-things and cup.

“Come on, my child, time you were up.

My goodness, lovely girl, you’re ready!

My early birdie, what a fright

You brought upon me yesternight.

But, heavens, how your health has steadied,

And last night’s fret has passed. Instead,

Your face has gone all poppy red.”

34

“Nanny, would you do me a favour?”

“Of course, my dear. How does it go?”

“You won’t think… there’s a funny flavour?…

You see… It’s like this… Don’t say no.”

“I won’t, my dear, God be your ransom.”

“Well, on the quiet get your grandson

To take this note to O… that man,

Our neighbour… Ask him, if he can,

To tell him nothing, just keep quiet

And be sure not to give my name.”

“But who’s it for, though? Such a shame—

I’m muddled now, I won’t deny it.

There’s lots of neighbours hereabouts,

Too many, more than I can count.”

35

“Oh dear, you are slow-witted, Nanny.”

“I’m getting on, dear, getting on…

My mind is dull now, not so canny.

Once it was sharp, but now it’s gone.

Time was, with one word from the master…”

“Oh, Nanny, dear, try to move faster.

What has your mind to do with me?

It’s all about this letter. See,

It’s for Onegin.” “Such a business…

Darling, you mustn’t take offence.

You know me. I don’t make much sense…

You’ve gone all pale again. What is this?”

“It’s nothing, Nanny. Don’t delay.

Just send your grandson on his way.”

36

A day passed, and Tatyana tarried.

No answer—and next day, the same.

She got dressed early, looking pallid.

When would he write—what was his game?

Then Olga’s suitor came to see them.

“He’s your close friend—where can he be, then?”

The mistress asked him, curious.

“I’m sure he’s quite forgotten us.”

Tatyana, meanwhile, blushed and shivered.

“He said today he would come by,”

Lensky confided in reply.

“He’ll come—the post is being delivered.”

At which Tatyana dropped her eyes

Like someone suddenly chastised.

37

Dusk settles. On the table, seething,

The evening samovar now sings

And warms the Chinese teapot, wreathing

Its clouds of steam in rising rings.

Dispensed by Olga’s expert fingers,

The tea is poured, its odour lingers

In a dark aromatic stream,

And a young boy goes round with cream.

Tatyana, by the table brooding,

My sweet soul, breathes on the cold glass

And ponders as the moments pass,

Her gorgeous tiny finger doodling…

The pane is steamed, the message brief:

Y.O. She cherished the motif.

38

Sinking in spirit, she felt shattered;

Her languid eyes filled up with tears.

Hoof beats! Her heart froze as they clattered

Into the yard—and he appeared,

Yevgeny! Shadow-like, the lassie

Slips out into another passage…

Porch, yard and garden are attacked,

She flies and flies, not looking back,

Not daring to, as on she rushes

Past edges, bridges, onward drawn

Towards the lake, across the lawn,

Crashing her way through lilac bushes,

Past neat beds to the brook. The wench

Was breathless when, reaching a bench,

39

She flopped…

                        “It’s him! He’s here! Yevgeny!

Good gracious! What can he have thought?”

Her agonizing heart is straining,

With a dark dream of hope restored.

She shakes. Her temperature has risen.

She waits. Is this him?… No, it isn’t.

Out in the beds the maids, by chance,

Were picking berries from the plants,

And singing, as decreed, in chorus

(A rule intended to preclude

The master’s berries being chewed

By opportunist mouths—a flawless

Country device that substitutes

Singing aloud for scrumping fruits).

SONG OF THE GIRLS

Come, ye pretty maidens, come,

Little darlings, little friends,

Frolic, maidens, have your fun,

Dance and play and dance again.

Sing your song, oh, sing your song,

Secret and mysterious,

Lead your lad, bring him along,

Make him join the dance with us.

When you’ve seen him from afar,

When you’ve lured him into place,

Break and run, girls, where you are,

Throw your cherries in his face.

Cherries! Raspberries! Come near.

Berries round and berries red!

Do not try to overhear

Secrets sung and secrets said,

Do not try to watch the way

Maidens dance and maidens play.

40

She never thought—what was their song for?

The ringing voices passed her by.

Tatyana now could only long for

The tremor in her heart to die

And for her cheeks to cease their burning.

But in her breast the pain kept churning,

Warmth in her cheeks did not disperse,

Indeed it blazed up even worse.

Thus a poor butterfly will shimmer

And give one rainbow wing a flap

When caught in a rough schoolboy’s trap.

Thus, in the corn, a hare will quiver

When from afar he sees what’s what—

There in the bushes huntsmen squat.

41

But soon she gave a sigh of yearning

And stood up from the garden seat.

She walked away… The path, the turning,

The avenue… Whom should she meet

But him, with eyes ablaze—Yevgeny!—

A presence ominous and shady.

As if scorched by some fiery bolt,

She staggered slowly to a halt.

But… what came next, that subject matter

Lies at this time beyond my strength;

I cannot tell it now, my friends.

Having indulged in so much chatter,

I need to rest and have some fun.

I’ll finish this off later on.

* She was a girl, she was in love. (French.)

CHAPTER FOUR

La morale est dans la nature des choses.*

NECKER

[1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6] 7

The less we prize and love a woman

The more she’ll like us, and perhaps

The more she’ll be inclined to come on,

Lured into our enticing traps.

It used to be that cold seduction

Counted as amorous instruction,

Vaunting itself, consisting of

Enjoyment not involving love,

But this game, once a major pastime

Was suited to the apes of old

Much praised in granddad’s days.